Obsidian vs Black Tourmaline vs Onyx: How to Tell Them Apart

A glossy black obsidian chunk, a striated black tourmaline crystal and a polished black onyx sphere

Quick Answer

Look at shape and surface first. Black tourmaline grows as long crystals with fine grooves running along their length and a rounded triangular cross-section. Obsidian is volcanic glass: glassy shine, smooth curved chips and sometimes stretched bubbles under a loupe. Black onyx is dyed chalcedony with an even, waxy black and faint bands at a thin edge under strong light. For polished stones, only a gem lab can confirm which is which.

On this page
  1. What Is the Difference Between Obsidian, Black Tourmaline and Onyx?
  2. How Can You Tell Black Tourmaline Apart by Its Crystal Shape?
  3. How Do You Spot Obsidian and Tell It From Black Glass?
  4. How Do You Know If Black Onyx Is Dyed or Natural?
  5. Can a Scratch Test or Hardness Kit Tell Them Apart?
  6. When Do You Need a Gem Lab?
  7. Frequently Asked Questions
  8. Our Take
  9. Sources

Key Takeaways

  • Obsidian is glass with no crystal structure; black tourmaline is a crystal with lengthwise grooves; black onyx is microcrystalline quartz (chalcedony), usually dyed.
  • Rough black tourmaline is the easiest to spot: long, grooved crystals with a three-sided outline.
  • A uniform jet-black onyx is normally dyed; GIA says virtually all black chalcedony on the market is treated.
  • Polished beads and cabochons often cannot be told apart by eye. Certainty needs refractive index, specific gravity or other lab tests.
  • Never scratch-test finished jewelry or a seller's stone; hardness testing damages the piece.

What Is the Difference Between Obsidian, Black Tourmaline and Onyx?

The three stones differ in what they are made of and how their atoms are arranged, and that difference drives everything you can see.

Obsidian is glass made by a volcano. Calvin University's geology collection describes it as an extrusive igneous rock that forms when silica-rich molten rock cools so fast that its atoms cannot arrange themselves into crystals; the result is a volcanic glass with a smooth, uniform texture that breaks conchoidally [8]. James Madison University's rock guide adds that typical obsidian is very black, shiny and glassy, with smooth curved breaks that often show concentric ridges [9]. Because it is a rock-glass rather than a mineral, it has no crystal faces of its own. See the obsidian profile for its varieties.

Black tourmaline is a crystal. GIA lists schorl as one of the five major tourmaline species, typically black and rich in iron, and notes that it is rarely used as a gem, although it appeared in mourning jewelry [2]. The Handbook of Mineralogy describes schorl crystals as prismatic, with a prominent trigonal (three-sided) prism, commonly striated parallel to their length, and reaching up to 1.5 m (about 5 feet) [7]. More on the black tourmaline profile.

Black onyx is (usually) dyed chalcedony. GIA explains that onyx, like agate and jasper, is a variety of chalcedony, a microcrystalline quartz, and that natural onyx is made of straight parallel layers of different colors. It also states that what many call "black onyx" is actually dyed black chalcedony, and that natural black chalcedony is rare, so virtually all of it is treated [4]. If a piece of "onyx" is a perfectly even, deep black, assume it has been dyed unless a lab report says otherwise.

FeatureObsidianBlack tourmaline (schorl)Black onyx
What it isNatural volcanic glassSingle-crystal mineralChalcedony (microcrystalline quartz), usually dyed
Mohs hardnessAbout 6 (GCC collection)7 to 7.5 (GIA)7 (GIA)
Natural shapeGlassy masses, no crystal facesLong prisms, 3-sided outline, lengthwise groovesLayers in nodules and veins
FractureGlassy, smooth, curved (conchoidal)Uneven to conchoidal, brittleWaxy, fine-grained, can look conchoidal
LusterGlassyGlassy to resinousWaxy to glassy when polished
Tell-tale signsStretched bubbles, smooth shell-like breaksGrooves, triangular cross-section, white streakEven black, faint bands at a thin edge
Common treatmentRarely treatedRarely treatedDyed black (disclosure required)

Hardness sources: Greenfield Community College's geology collection lists its obsidian sample at 6 on the Mohs scale [10]; GIA gives 7 to 7.5 for tourmaline [1] and 7 for onyx (GIA blog above). Obsidian figures vary between references because glass composition varies, so treat that number as approximate.

How Can You Tell Black Tourmaline Apart by Its Crystal Shape?

Rough or raw black tourmaline is the one stone of the three you can often recognize on sight, because its crystal form survives. Look for three things:

  1. Grooves along the length. Fine parallel ridges, called striations, run from one end of the crystal to the other. The Handbook of Mineralogy notes that schorl is commonly striated parallel to its long axis [7].
  2. A three-sided outline. Look at the broken end of a crystal. The trigonal prism gives it a rounded triangular cross-section rather than a round or square one.
  3. Long, pencil-like proportions. GIA notes that the elongated shape of many tourmaline crystals affects how gems are cut, which is why cutters often follow the crystal's length [3].

Obsidian never shows these features, because glass does not grow crystal faces. Chalcedony is a mass of crystals too small to see, so it does not form big prisms either.

What to look for on each black stone Three panels. Left, black tourmaline: a long crystal with parallel grooves along its length, and its end view showing a rounded triangle. Middle, obsidian: a chip with curved, shell-like ridges and stretched gas bubbles drawn as thin ovals. Right, black onyx: a cabochon whose thin edge, lit by a strong light, shows faint parallel bands. Tell-tale features at a glance TourmalineObsidianOnyx grooves end: 3-sided curved ridges, stretched bubbles (10x) bands at a thin edge under a strong light Polished beads often hide all three clues.
Rough tourmaline shows its grooves and triangular outline; obsidian shows glassy shell-like breaks and, under a loupe, stretched bubbles; dyed onyx may reveal bands only at a thin, brightly lit edge. Based on the Handbook of Mineralogy and GIA's Gems & Gemology.

Two more home clues for tourmaline: the Handbook lists a white streak and a vitreous to resinous luster for schorl, and a measured density of 3.18 to 3.22 [7]. Density is something a lab measures precisely; by hand it is only a vague impression. A streak test means rubbing the stone on unglazed porcelain, and GIA's black-opaque study calls it a destructive test that must be made carefully [6], so it belongs on your own rough specimens only.

How Do You Spot Obsidian and Tell It From Black Glass?

Obsidian's clues come from being glass. Its broken edges are smooth and curved, like the inside of a shell, and razor sharp. Calvin University notes that this conchoidal fracture is why ancient cultures shaped obsidian into knives, arrowheads and spear points [8]. Check the girdle of a cabochon or the drill hole of a bead with a loupe for small chips; a bright, glassy shell-shaped chip fits obsidian.

The harder problem is telling obsidian from man-made black glass, which is sold under many names. GIA's study of black opaque gems points to the inclusions: manufactured glass tends to hold round gas bubbles, while natural volcanic glass shows stretched gas bubbles and iron-titanium oxide inclusions [6]. Many black stones are too dark to see inside, so you may need a strong penlight held against a thin edge to see anything at all.

If you see perfectly round bubbles, mold seams or a surface that looks pressed rather than polished, suspect glass. For the wider picture on fakes and treated stones, our guide on how to spot dyed crystals covers the same loupe routine.

How Do You Know If Black Onyx Is Dyed or Natural?

For black onyx, the realistic question is not "dyed or natural" but "dyed chalcedony or something else". GIA's black-opaque study notes that a uniform black is often achieved by dyeing a porous material, and that the banding in a "black onyx" cabochon may be visible only on a very thin edge under strong fiber-optic light; the stone may have been a banded agate before treatment, or layers may have absorbed the dye differently [6].

What you can check at home:

  • Color. An even, inky black with no zoning at all fits dyed chalcedony. Natural onyx shows straight bands of different colors.
  • Thin edges. Shine a bright penlight through the thinnest edge of a bead hole or cabochon rim. Faint parallel bands support chalcedony.
  • Chips. GIA notes that fine, compact aggregates such as chalcedony may break with a waxy, conchoidal surface, while glass and single crystals give a glassy one. A waxy chip points toward chalcedony.

Dyed black onyx is a durable, honest material when it is sold as what it is. In the United States, the FTC Guides say it is unfair or deceptive to fail to disclose a gemstone treatment that is not permanent, that creates special care requirements, or that significantly affects value [11]. Expect listings for black onyx to say "dyed".

Care follows from the dye. GIA advises keeping dyed gems away from solvents such as alcohol and acetone, which can remove many dyes, and out of prolonged sunlight, which can fade them [5]. Our crystal jewelry cleaning guide and the care chart set out safe cleaning for each stone, and which crystals fade in sunlight explains why dyes are the weak point.

Can a Scratch Test or Hardness Kit Tell Them Apart?

Only partly, and only on rough pieces you own. The numbers explain why: tourmaline (7 to 7.5) and onyx (7) sit so close together on the Mohs scale that a hardness kit barely separates them, while obsidian, at about 6, is softer than both.

Mohs hardness of obsidian, onyx and black tourmaline A Mohs scale from 1 to 10. Obsidian is marked at about 6, black onyx at 7, and black tourmaline across 7 to 7.5. Onyx and tourmaline overlap, so a hardness kit separates obsidian from the other two but barely separates onyx from tourmaline. Mohs hardness: close neighbors 12345678910 Obsidian ~6 Onyx 7 Tourmaline 7-7.5 Onyx and tourmaline overlap: a kit barely splits them. Sources: GIA (onyx, tourmaline); GCC collection (obsidian).
Hardness separates obsidian from the other two, but onyx and black tourmaline sit side by side. Hardness tests also leave marks, so they are for rough specimens you own, never for jewelry.

GIA's black-opaque study lists hardness testing under tests that are not recommended for gemstones, because it requires scratching the sample [6]. Never scratch-test finished jewelry, a polished bead, or a stone that belongs to a seller. If you collect rough specimens and want to use a hardness kit, test only an unpolished, hidden spot of a piece you own, and read the result as a hint. Our Mohs hardness guide for crystal jewelry explains how hardness also predicts which stones scuff in daily wear.

When Do You Need a Gem Lab?

You need a lab whenever the answer matters: an expensive piece, a stone sold with a specific name, or polished beads with no visible clues. GIA's study opens by saying that refractive index, specific gravity and microscopic appearance give useful clues, but that in most cases advanced techniques such as X-ray diffraction or EDXRF spectroscopy are needed to identify a black opaque material, and even these may not be conclusive [6].

The refractive index gives a lab a quick first split. GIA lists tourmaline at 1.624 to 1.644 [1], and the Handbook of Mineralogy gives a measured density of 3.18 to 3.22 for schorl. A gemologist compares readings like these with the known values for chalcedony and glass, takes them from several spots on the stone, and does so without harming it.

Identification flow for a black stone A flow chart. Step 1: does the stone show long lengthwise grooves and a three-sided outline? If yes, likely black tourmaline. If no, step 2: are faint bands visible at a thin edge under strong light, with a waxy chip? If yes, likely dyed chalcedony sold as black onyx. If no, step 3: glassy curved chips and bubbles under a 10x loupe? Stretched bubbles suggest obsidian; round bubbles suggest man-made glass. Every branch ends at: confirm with a gem lab for certainty. Which black stone is it? 1. Lengthwise grooves and a 3-sided outline? Likely black tourmaline yes no 2. Faint bands at a thin edge under strong light, waxy chip, perfectly even black? Likely dyed chalcedony ("black onyx") yes no 3. Glassy, shell-shaped chips? Check bubbles with a 10x loupe and strong light. Stretched bubbles, likely obsidian Round bubbles, likely man-made glass Every branch: confirm with a gem lab (refractive index, SG, spectroscopy) Polished beads may show none of these clues.
Home checks narrow the choice; they do not prove it. Based on GIA's Gems & Gemology study of black opaque gem materials and the Handbook of Mineralogy.

When you buy, ask the seller to name the material and any treatment in writing. A clear listing for "dyed black onyx" or "obsidian" beats a vague "black crystal". If you are choosing a piece by look and daily wear rather than by identity, the jewelry finder sorts options by use, and the shop lists the tools mentioned here, including loupes and hardness kits for rough specimens.

Useful for this guide

Frequently Asked Questions

Is black onyx the same as obsidian?

No. Black onyx is chalcedony, a microcrystalline form of quartz that is almost always dyed black, while obsidian is natural volcanic glass with no crystal structure. Onyx is a little harder (7 on the Mohs scale versus about 6 for obsidian) and breaks with a waxier surface; obsidian breaks with glassy, shell-shaped edges.

Is black tourmaline the same as schorl?

Mostly, yes. Schorl is the iron-rich tourmaline species that is typically black, and it is what most "black tourmaline" specimens are. Other tourmaline species can also look very dark, so a gemologist uses refractive index and other tests to confirm the species.

Which is harder, black tourmaline or onyx?

They are almost the same. GIA lists tourmaline at 7 to 7.5 and onyx at 7 on the Mohs scale, so both resist everyday scratches better than obsidian. Tourmaline is brittle, though, and both can chip if knocked against a hard edge.

Can you tell these stones apart in a bead bracelet?

Often not by eye. Tumbling and drilling remove tourmaline's grooves and obsidian's chips, leaving three shiny black spheres. A loupe and a strong light at the drill hole may show bands or bubbles, but only lab tests can confirm the material.

Our Take

We think the most useful habit is to stop treating "black stone" as one category. In our view, rough black tourmaline is the only one of the three most buyers can name with confidence, thanks to its grooves and triangular outline. For polished pieces, we would trust a clear written description from the seller over any home test, and we would expect black onyx to be disclosed as dyed, because GIA says nearly all of it is. That is not a flaw: dyed onyx is a durable, sensible choice for everyday jewelry. And we would never scratch a stone to settle the question; a gem lab answers it without damage.

Sources

  1. Tourmaline. GIA.
  2. Tourmaline Description. GIA.
  3. Tourmaline Quality Factors. GIA.
  4. Wedding Anniversary Gemstone List: Years One through 10. GIA.
  5. An Introduction to Gem Treatments. GIA.
  6. Some Gemological Challenges in Identifying Black Opaque Gem Materials. GIA Gems & Gemology.
  7. Schorl. Handbook of Mineralogy.
  8. Obsidian - Volcanic Glass. Calvin University.
  9. Obsidian. James Madison University.
  10. R206 - Richard D. Little Geology Collection. Greenfield Community College.
  11. 16 CFR 23.24 - Disclosure of treatments to gemstones. Cornell Law School LII.

Crystal Field Guide covers mineralogy, identification and care. We make no claims that any stone affects health, mood or fortune. Home checks can only suggest an answer; for certainty about a valuable stone, ask an accredited gem lab. Spotted an error? Tell us.